[1] At 17, she released her first full-length album, Memories in Melody[2] as her senior project at Moon Area High School.

[2][7] The album garnered positive reviews from writers in Pittsburgh and Brian Palmer of Glide Magazine called it "phenomenal" writing, "Filled with gravitas, passion, joy, sorrow, humility and boldness, the ten tracks that make up Silence Worth Breaking are done in a stunning, hypnotic fashion, encompassing the genres of folk, rock, Americana and pop in masterful ways.

"[5] Words in Your Eyes, was released February 5, 2013[8] and featured at an official launch performance at Club Cafe in Pittsburgh, on March 9, 2013.

[10] Produced by Justin March at Paul Moak's Smoakstack studio in Nashville,[11] the album release was followed by a breakout year for Annibale and then continuous touring with artists including Iron & Wine, Josh Ritter, Margaret Glaspy, Great Lake Swimmers, Jesca Hoop, Rufus Wainwright, The Handsome Family, Chadwick Stokes, and Aoife O'Donovan.

[12] In March 2018, Annibale announced her latest full-length studio album Hold to the Light which was released on June 8, 2018.