The event was continued in 2004 as the Cacowards, with an emphasis on discussing the year's most notable contributions to the Doom modding community.

[1] The name of the Cacowards stems from Doom's "Cacodemon" monster, whose likeness is present in the award's design.

Commenting on the event, PC Gamer stated: "If you want a direct route to the best Doom maps and mods, the place to go is the Cacowards.

"[5] Rock, Paper, Shotgun shared a similar sentiment, commenting that the Cacowards are "often a handy pointer towards good and fun new things.

"[6] Numerous award recipients have received additional commendations by journalists covering the Cacowards, who often review highlights from the year's ceremony.