In the first year, the vestry hired the architect William Nichols to design the building and oversee its construction.

Twenty-five pews were placed in the church and were sold for bids ranging from $75 to $150 or were rented for $8 a year.

An organ was installed in 1830 when the building was finished, but in 1941 the console was moved from the south to the north side of the chancel.

In 1984 a narthex was added on the west end of the nave to protect the church from street noise, and at the same time, a cloistered walk was built from the education building and the bell tower.

Thirty-five stained glass windows add colorful inspiration to the buildings on the property: seventeen in the main church, eight in the parish hall, six in the chapel, four in the narthex and a domed ceiling in the chancel.