[2] In 2017, Satterwhite sold the club to Cincinnati sports investor Jared Davis who immediately paused operations[3] before dissolving the organization in 2019 after a yearlong playing hiatus.

The club moved to the Professional Arena Soccer League for the 2013–14 season, playing in the Eastern Division under the leadership of head coach Chris Morman.

With 7 games remaining in the regular season, only the Illinois Piasa carried a worse record in the Eastern Division and the team parted ways with original head coach Matt Brienes on January 8, naming former player Chris Morman as his interim replacement.

[10] Halfway through the 2016 season, Wall was replaced as coach by his assistant, Dan Griest, who remained in charge through the Dynamo's last game.

[12] As of May 31, 2017[update] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.