While situated at OVW, he wrestled under the name Dice Domino and was placed in tag team competition, alongside Deuce Shade.

The team's name was changed to Deuce 'n Domino for their main roster debut in January 2007, as part of the SmackDown!

Compton became a regular for World Xtreme Wrestling, where he formed a tag team with Jake Bishop, known as Double Threat.

After four months at OVW, Compton began working as "Dice Domino", teaming with Deuce Shade under the management of his storyline sister Cherry Pie, using a 1950s greaser in-ring persona, forming the faction "The Throw-Backs".

[7] The Untouchables lost their titles on April 5, in a three-way match to Roadkill and Kasey James, which also involved Kenny and Mikey of The Spirit Squad.

[11] Deuce 'n Domino faced London and Kendrick in a WWE Tag Team Championship match at February's pay-per-view event, No Way Out.

Kendrick was left to defend the title by himself, and was pinned after being hit with the West Side Stomp, a finishing move performed by Deuce 'n Domino.

[17][18][19] On the August 31 episode of SmackDown!, he and Deuce lost their tag team championship to Matt Hardy and the reigning United States Champion Montel Vontavious Porter.

[20] During the last few months of 2007, Deuce 'n Domino had short rivalries with Hardy and MVP,[21][22][23] Jimmy Wang Yang and Shannon Moore,[24] Jesse and Festus,[25][26] and Finlay and Hornswoggle.

At WrestleMania XXIV in March, Deuce and Domino competed as singles competitors in a 24-man Interpromotional Battle Royal, in which the winner would face then ECW Champion Chavo Guerrero Jr. later that night; however, neither was able to win the match.

[29] On the May 23 episode of SmackDown, Deuce 'n Domino parted ways with Cherry; WWE Diva Maryse would take over as the team's on-screen manager.

[39] After a four-month undefeated streak, on January 8, 2011, Compton defeated then–champion "Low Rider" Matt Barela and Mike Mondo in a three-way match to win the OVW Heavyweight Championship for the first time.

[47] On October 4, Compton won his third OVW Heavyweight Championship after pinning Marcus Anthony in a three-way match, also involving champion Melvin Maximus.

On March 2, 2013, Compton made his debut for Ring of Honor (ROH) at their 11th Anniversary Show iPPV, where he, Jimmy Rave, Matt Hardy and Rhett Titus, revealed themselves as the newest members of S.C.U.M.

[53][54] In May, Compton and Steen found common enemies and defeated Eddie Kingston and Homicide in a Charm City Street Fight.

[55] Almost one year later, March 14, 2015, Compton returned to challenge Jay Lethal for a chance to earn a shot at the ROH World Television Championship on the spot.

[57] Thirteen years after the separation, Treiber along with Reiher and Drew reformed the Deuce 'n Domino stable and now accept bookings in the independent circuit.

[59] In April 2014, a documentary titled, The Wrestling Road Diaries Too featuring Compton, Colt Cabana and Drew Hankinson, was released on DVD.