The Orediggers claimed the institution's first-ever Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference (RMAC) All-Sports Cup during the 2011–12 academic year, and repeated in 2015–16.

The men's cross country team placed 2nd at the 2012 NCAA Division II championships; finishing with 5 all-Americans.

The team posted the largest margin of victory in meet history with a 143-point win over runner-up Wingate.

Under his leadership, the team was Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference co-champions in 2016 and progressed to the second round of the NCAA playoffs.

Under Stitt, the football team was the RMAC champions in 2004 and co-champions in 2010 and 2014, and progressed to the second round of the NCAA playoffs in 2004.