It stars Katie Walder and Matt Passmore as a married couple who experience unexplained night terrors after a new neighbor (Nathan Keyes) moves in across the street.

Now on her own, Sarah installs hidden video surveillance cameras to record herself so she can better understand her night terrors, but they reveal that Dale has been entering the house, raping and murdering her, and then resurrecting her.

When Leslie gives birth, she is confused when the baby does not look like either of the possible fathers, and she recalls the video evidence of Sarah's rape, knowing that she had prior contact with Dale when he delivered her groceries, too.

As Dale dies, all of the victims that he has murdered and revived suddenly drop dead of their previous wounds, including Sarah, Josh, and Leslie.

[4] Frank Scheck of The Hollywood Reporter wrote, "A terrific premise is squandered in this ineffective horror film, which nonetheless has a truly disturbing climax.

"[6] Gary Goldstein of the Los Angeles Times called it a "exceedingly far-fetched" film that "borrows the best bits from several horror classics to great effect".

[8] Tirdad Derakhshani of The Philadelphia Inquirer wrote, "A grisly supernatural slasher that boasts a devilishly clever twist, Leyden's film lacks the sophistication to allow its unique idea to flower into much more than a gimmick.

"[9] Paul Doro of Shock Till You Drop called it "one strange, disjointed, and moderately compelling little movie" that may appeal to fans of "hard-to-categorize oddities".

[10] Scott Hallam of Dread Central wrote, "Definitely one to take a look at, Come Back to Me is a very entertaining story with some great performances and a director who deftly puts it all together.