Initially, a temporary constitution was written by a three-person committee, and a board of trustees was elected.

Members of the board included Harvey Beiler, Chairman; Omar Stolzfus, Vice-Chairman; and John C. Kurtz, Secretary.

By 1957, the school had ten grades and a third room, where Harry Hertzler taught and served as principal.

There were five full-time teachers, 112 students in first through tenth grades, a school newsletter, home economics and woodshop classes, a vending machine, a newly stocked science lab, and monthly fire drills.

[3] In 2007 the College Board announced that high school calculus and biology courses at Conestoga Christian had been authorized to use the Advanced Placement (AP) designation for the 2007-2008 academic year.