[2] The 1904 official Southern Tier League standings and statistics are unknown,[2][3] but newspaper accounts had the Coudersport team in last place with a 9–19 record on August 21, 1904.
[5] The Bradford Drillers, Erie Fishermen, Jamestown Hill Climbers, Kane Mountaineers and Olean Refiners teams joined the Giants in beginning league play of April 25, 1905.
With Harry Knight and John Lawley serving as managers, Coudersport finished 1.0 game ahead of the second place Erie Fisherman (58–39).
[10][9] Future major league players Rube Kroh and Herbie Moran played for the Coudersport Giants.
The Erie Sailors, Oil City-Jamestown Oseejays and Punxsutawney Policemen were the new franchises in the 1906 Interstate League.