[6] However, the quality of racing at the venue was not strong, and the racecourse's short existence came to an end in 1873, when the lease expired and much of the land was sold for housing.

[8] A smaller grassed oval was retained behind the hotel, still used for running, hunting, pigeon shooting,[9] and occasionally for football and cricket.

The fact that Croxton Park adjoined a private licensed establishment became a source of ongoing controversy.

It gained a reputation for unruly and drunken behaviour of its patrons,[13] and the direct connection between the grounds and the hotel was opposed by local churches and the temperance movement.

The following year, the rival Rose of Northcote Football Club was formed, also in the VJFA, and was permitted to play at Croxton Park throughout its existence from 1904 until 1908.

This pony racing venue on the western side of St Georges Rd operated from 1891 until 1931, and was privately owned by John Wren, but was never directly associated with the Croxton Park Hotel.