It was released on 26 September 2011 through Ape Planet and features guest appearances from Wizkid, M.I, 2Face Idibia, Banky W. and Flavour.

Ayomide Tayo of Nigerian Entertainment Today described the album as unimaginative and one-dimensional, criticizing its repetitive rhythms, weak lyrics, and lackluster production.

While praising collaborations like "Girl" with Wizkid and "Champion" with Banky W., he concluded that "Cupid Stories is a book of forgettable love tales" and rated it 2.5 out of 5.

[9] Wilfred Okiche of YNaija described Cupid Stories as a love-themed album with moments of charm but weighed down by inconsistent quality.

While praising tracks like "Beautiful Baby" featuring Flavour and "Remember" with 2Face Idibia, he noted the album’s weaker songs and concluded, "We will be making room on our playlists for the better melodious tunes on this set while wishing the guys Godspeed in perfecting their sound, but we will not wait around forever.