McCoy retired from international competition in 2018 but continues to play within North America on the Pittsburgh Mighty Penguins Sled Hockey Senior team where is a player/coach.

[citation needed] His older brother, Andrew, is a Fellow in Pediatrics Rehabilitation at the University of Colorado's Children's Hospital.[relevant?]

[citation needed] McCoy is one of the original players in the Mighty Penguins Sled Hockey organization and still competes with the senior team as captain.

[citation needed] At the age of 8, McCoy watched the 2002 Salt Lake City Paralympic Games in which a fellow Mighty Penguins player, Josh Wirt, was a member of the U.S. National Sled Hockey Team.

[citation needed] In addition to playing sled hockey, McCoy enjoys handcycling and has competed in several Pittsburgh Marathons.