Bingham signed a Generation Adidas contract with Major League Soccer soon after the 2011 MLS SuperDraft.

[3] He scored a goal on a 90-yard clearance from his own penalty box on July 13, 2011, against West Bromwich Albion in an exhibition match at Buck Shaw Stadium.

[4] After spending time on loan with the San Antonio Scorpions and Strømmen IF,[5] Bingham emerged as a starter for the Earthquakes during the 2015 season.

[6] On January 13, 2022, after a year without a club, Bingham signed a two-year deal with Portland Timbers.

[8] Bingham made his debut with the United States national team on February 5, 2016, against Canada, playing the full match and keeping a clean sheet in a 1–0 victory.