He attended East Hartford High School where he was a varsity starter in soccer for two years and was named all-conference in 2017.

He was also named United Soccer Coaches Division III third team after leading the conference in scoring with 21 goals.

[6] Agyemang was also included on the MAC Hermann Trophy Watch list going into his final season with Rhode Island.

[7] While at college, Agyemang also competed in the USL League Two with Western Mass Pioneers in 2021, scoring six goals in 15 appearances across the regular season and playoffs as he helped the team win the Eastern Conference title.

Charlotte traded their first-round pick in the 2024 MLS SuperDraft, in addition to up to $100,000 of General Allocation Money in order to draft him.