[1] Their initial success spawned from their 2005 EP What really happened at Lover's Lane on Verona Records (a label created by the band themselves, and Silverstein's Shane Told).

[2] Their first EP, What really happened at Lover's Lane sold nearly 1000 copies nationwide, landing them a spot on the Canadian Billboard chart.

In July 2008, it was announced that Ryan Leger would leave the band in order to be with his girlfriend and newborn daughter.

In August 2009, they shot a video for "Neon Jesus" with director Marc Ricciardelli, which was released on September 18, 2009.

[13] On November 4, 2019, guitarist Chris LeMasters launched a new project called Teeth with ex-members of Every Time I die, Norma Jean, and Straight reads the Line.