Their remains were eventually found in Foster's submerged vehicle in the Calfkiller River in 2021 by Jeremy Sides, a volunteer civilian cold-case investigator and YouTuber.
[5] No one saw them alive after the evening of April 3, 2000, prompting rumors and speculation of their whereabouts including false reports of sightings.
[3][4] On November 24, 2021, scuba diver Jeremy Sides searched a lake near the location of the party attended by the teenagers.
[4] On November 30, using sonar technology, Sides found a vehicle located thirteen feet below the surface of the Calfkiller River, next to Highway 84,[1] before running out of daylight.
[4] He called White County Sheriff Steve Page to report his discovery and to confirm that it was Foster's car with human remains found inside.