[7] Jazz of 360nobs described Double Dare as a showcase of Darey’s versatility and mastery, balancing soulful ballads on Heart with dance tracks on Beat.

The review highlighted his vocal ability and songwriting, praising standout tracks like “Pillow,” “Ba Ni Kidi,” and “Close,” and noted that the album caters to diverse audiences.

Rating the project 7.8/10, Jazz concluded, “Darey is without a doubt the ‘King of Nigerian R&B,’” and recommended owning both volumes to fully appreciate his artistry.

[8] Ayomide Tayo in his review for Nigerian Entertainment Today praised Double Dare for its creativity and versatility, calling it a bold release that "proves that he is the true King of R&B".

He highlighted the dual nature of the album, describing Heart as "an astounding collection of songs that move at an even pace" and Beat as delivering "dope pop and dance tracks" with Darey adapting seamlessly to diverse styles and collaborations.