Signaling in a four star review for CCM Magazine, Matt Conner writes, "While the songs on Aaron Shust's latest album, Doxology, are rooted in solid theology and church tradition they're also more festive and celebratory than the title might suggest.

"[5] Awarding the album four and a half stars at Worship Leader, Kristen Gilles states, "Doxology is a congregation-friendly collection of praise anthems celebrating the resurrection, rule, and reign of Jesus Christ.

"[9] Caitlin Lassiter, giving the album four and a half stars for New Release Today, says, "We can count Doxology another success from Aaron as we worship along with him in response to God's eternal goodness.

"[4] Sarah Baylor, indicating in a four and a half review for The Christian Beat, recognizes, "This whole album is worshipful, energetic, and an exquisite gem.

"[3] Rating the album a 2.5 out of five from The Phantom Tollbooth, Marie Asner writes, "This is a collection of songs for praise and thankfulness with an upbeat aspect to the music.