During his time with the Packers, Policy helped develop the Titletown District and began taking on more responsibility in the business operations of the team.
[9] Faced when financial challenges, the AFL attempted a reorganization by cancelling the 2009 season, providing time for a new business model to develop.
[10] Policy noted in announcing the suspension that the owners and players were still committed to the league, but that the AFL needed to develop better long term financial sustainability.
[4] In 2012 the Green Bay Packers hired Policy to serve as vice president and general counsel, after the departure of Jason Weid.
[14] During his time as an executive, Policy has worked in almost every facet of the Packers' day-to-day operations, including legal affairs, security, community engagement and overall governance of the team.
[18] The Titletown District is a mixed-use development with community amenities owned and operated by the Packers, providing additional non-football-related revenue.
[19][20] In June 2024, the Packers announced Policy would replace Mark Murphy as the team's president and chief executive officer in July 2025.
[23] Policy, whose first marriage ended in divorce, married Christina Less, daughter of United States Navy Vice Admiral Anthony A.