He played for Yorkshire's second eleven in both the Minor Counties and Second Eleven Championship competitions between 1954 and 1959, winning the Minor Counties Championship in both 1957 and 1958.
[1] But he was unable to dislodge his contemporary Jimmy Binks from the Yorkshire first team, and Binks' remarkable immunity from injury and from being rested meant there were no opportunities whatsoever, so from 1960, Legard started qualifying for Warwickshire.
From 1961, however, the former Oxford University captain A. C. Smith became Warwickshire's regular wicketkeeper, and Legard's opportunities were again restricted.
Against Oxford University in that season, he had seven wicketkeeping victims in the match, with six catches and one stumping, three of the catches coming off the bowling of Smith who, after Legard had left the county, increasingly turned his hand to medium-pace bowling.
[2] In the mid-1960s, however, Legard was not able to displace Smith from the regular first team as wicketkeeper, and after the 1964 season his appearances over the remaining four years that he was on the Warwickshire staff were confined to non-Championship matches; of his 20 first-class games in all, only four were in the Championship.