He played in Philadelphia clubs from the 1950s and was in organist Jimmy Smith's band for several recordings in 1957–58.

[5] McFadden continued performing with Smith in a trio with drummer Donald Bailey, including at the Hurricane club in Pittsburgh for several weeks during 1958.

[11] A further album – The Stinger Meets the Golden Thrush – from 1966[12] appears to have been the last time that the guitarist recorded with Smith.

In November 1967, the "Al Grey & Eddie McFadden Quartet" was advertised as playing at Count Basie's Lounge in New York.

[2] In September 1992, McFadden played at the White Horse Lounge on Lancaster Avenue in Philadelphia.