[2][3] On June 18, 1888, the Indiana State League folded in mid-season with Elkhart in second place, playing under manager Dave Carpenter.
Teams from Anderson, Bluffton, Fort Wayne Reds, Kokomo, Marion, Muncie and Peru joined Elkhart in beginning league play.
[6] On July 6, 1890, Elkhart disbanded from the league with a record of 14–28, playing under returning manager Dave Carpenter.
The league then folded on August 21, 1910, with the Elkhart Blue Sox in second place in the standings, playing under manager Charles Karnell.
[3][12][13][5] When the Indiana–Michigan League permanently folded on August 21, 1910, the Berrien Springs Grays finished 4.5 games ahead of second place Elkhart in the standings.
[20] The player rosters and statistics for the 1910 Indiana-Michigan League teams, Elkhart included, is unknown.