The club then decided to take a step down to the East Berkshire League Premier Division for the 2010–11 season after it no longer had a Reserve team.
A week later Eton Wick lost the Slough Town Senior Cup Final to Iver 1–0.
Now playing in East Berkshire Football League Division 1, the new Eton Wick Manager brought in current goalkeeper and former Willow Wanderers F.C.
Assistant Manager Phil O'Brien to help rebuild the team with hopes of reviving the club's successes of years gone by and take them back to the top of the East Berkshire Football League.
The 2020/21 season was again hit with a second and third national COVID-19 lockdown putting a halt to proceedings in November 2020 with no ball kicked nationwide until April 2021.