At CCM Magazine, Matt Conner felt that "the personal story of Everfound is interesting [...] their anthemic pop-rock is an equal draw", which he stated because of a few songs on the album it "shows the vast potential for this import.

"[2] Joshua Andre of Christian Music Zine called the album "one to savour over and over again", and told that his "listening experience [was] an enjoyable one.

"[3] At Digital Journal, Markos Papadatos felt that the release was "well-written", and noted that "Nikita soars on lead vocals and his brothers are delightful on harmonies.

"[5] Cimarron Hatch at Indie Vision Music felt that "these are all wonderful songs that have great messages for people to hear and enjoy.

"[4] At Jesus Freak Hideout, Mark Rice highlighted that the project "is a perfect example of a young band searching for their musical identity in the midst of an industry that requires a quota of radio songs on each album.