"[1] At CCM Magazine, Andrew Greer highlighted that "maintains mostly acoustic motifs from top to bottom...letting the easy-to-remember melodies and the duo's trademark harmonies lead the way.

"[3] Christian Broadcasting Network's Rob Vischer wrote that "The duo's impassioned harmonies still simmer over a raw acoustic set to create an organic "front row" experience.

"[6] At Christianity Today Andrea Dawn Goforth claimed that the duo is "folkier than ever here" and the album contains "backbeat rhythm on songs throughout" with "tight harmonies and poppy hooks".

[7] Julie Porter of Cross Rhythms alluded to how the listener "will hear a tinge Nashville, Tennessee in the crafted, acoustic pop" that "occasionally though a rock feel shows through".

[6] Logan Leasure of Jesus Freak Hideout highlighted that "the spiritual messages do justify giving Everything Is Different a spin at least", however, the "next time around, we'll hope for a little more risk, but for now, the duo that Christian music has come to love over the past decade remains in their stronghold.