In early 2011, The Ready Set began working on a new EP having already written 20 new songs and hoped for a release in the summer of that year.

[10] He described the single as, "a story about being a kid from a small town with a simple life, who falls in love with a famous, Beverly Hills-style girl.

[12] He explained the song as, "knowing you are not the type of person somebody should be in a relationship with, and sort of warning them to stay away.

[14][15] Feel Good Now was given a 3.5 star rating by AllMusic, and in its review by Tim Sendra, he calls it an "even more assured-sounding, extremely well-crafted pop."

Evan Lucy of Alternative Press was critical of the EP stating, "there’s not much diversity, something a sound like Witzigreuter’s sorely needs.