Awarding the album three and a half stars from Jesus Freak Hideout, Christopher Smith states, "Fightback Soundtrack is an enjoyable and encouraging listen".

[5] Giving the album four stars at New Release Today, Caitlin Lassiter writes, "Fightback Soundtrack seems to have an evolved, more mature sound".

[3] Rating the album 3.5 out of five for Christian Music Review, Laura Chambers writes, "We Are Leo seeks to inspire us to do more than drop back and be overtaken".

[2] Jonathan Andre, giving the album three and a half stars from 365 Days of Inspiring Media, says, "though sometimes sounding cliché and cheesy, is recorded well, and is a joy to hear these young men of God create meaningful pop/rock and dance music, that can transcend any belief system.

[4] Jessica Morris, rating the album 8.5 out of ten stars by Jesus Wired, describes, "We Are Leo's Fight Back Soundtrack is a testament to the band’s loyal fans".