[6] Many prominent locals from this time period are buried at this cemetery, including members of the Burtis family, which owned a farm located partially over what is now the North Hempstead Country Club.

[5][8] In 2010, a local resident, James Morgan McLaughlin, arranged a cleanup effort of the cemetery, as part of his Eagle Scout project.

[8] One year later, in 2011, ownership of the property was transferred from the Town of North Hempstead to the Village of Flower Hill.

[9] The cemetery was designated a Village of Flower Hill Historic Landmark on April 3, 2023.

[9] The Flower Hill Cemetery has a total of 8 headstones and 10 known interments.