The previous wooden building, constructed in 1867, was described as a "the eyesore of the main street", prompting calls for its replacement.
[5][6] The courthouse became the home of the Foxton Historical Society's museum collection.
[7] In 2013 the building was closed by the Horowhenua District Council as it was deemed an earthquake risk.
[8] The Foxton Historical Society has signaled its intention to fundraise to undertake the required earthquake strengthening and reopen the building as a museum.
[9] In February 2020 it was reported that the society was continuing to work on a business case for the development.