Since 2001, the boys' soccer team has built a program that has consistently been at the top of the McGrath South table and was a No.

On November 14, 2015, the boys' cross-country team qualified for the MIAA All-State for the first time in school history.

Before the 2008 run, the Frontier boys' basketball team had made numerous trips throughout the early and mid-2000s to the Western Massachusetts Division III Finals.

In the 2008 season after a start of 7–8, the Redhawks finished as MIAA DIII Western Mass champions, advancing as far as the state finals.

The girls' team, which is led by Bob Smith and Jim Recore, has a no-loss record dating back to 1998.

The boys' track team is coached by Walter Flynn and Kevin Seetal and won their first league title on May 9, 2011.

The Frontier School Committee voted to remove the Redskin mascot and delete any reference to the term.