The cemetery was originally the burying ground for the Protestant Dutch Church of Fultonville, but was transferred to the village in 1848.
The Starin Mausoleum no longer stands in Fultonville Cemetery, but remnants of the foundation can still be found.
Sometime around this time, it was also vandalized on Halloween, by a group of teenagers who destroyed most of the caskets and bodies.
Today, a modest upright granite slab with a bronze face marks Starin's grave and those of his family members.
[citation needed] In 2013, a section of Fultonville Cemetery was dedicated to "green" or natural burials, wherein bodies are buried shortly after death, without embalming, wrapped in shrouds or in wooden coffins that can decompose naturally.