In its first year of official play, the Indians finished in first place with an undefeated record in the Landesliga Group A and were promoted to the Bayernliga (Bavarian League).

Through reaching the Bayernliga for the 1993 season, the Gauting Indians saw their membership grow, allowing the club to begin offering youth baseball training.

The search for a piece of land to construct a field to meet the requirements of the Deutscher Baseball and Softball Verband e.V.

Wuermtal Baseball Park was also inaugurated in July of that year, becoming the permanent site of the Indians' home games.

In 1999 the Indians were awarded DM10,000 by the Gruene Band of Dresdner Bank in recognition of its work fostering baseball talent.

The first men's team also took on a foreign coach for the first time in club history, Canadian Mike Couliard, but finished in sixth place with a 20-16 record.

Despite importing two American players, Cory Monroe and Marc Hagander, the first men's team finished in fifth place.

That year the Gauting Indians recorded 140 members participating in six teams in official play, ranking it among the three largest baseball clubs in Bavaria.

Under coach Matthew Laack and with new Italian import Francesco Vitocco, the first men's team succeeded in advancing to the first division of the Bundesliga.

The first men's team, under coach Michael Almstetter, and supported by imports Ben Regan, Tristan McDonald and Ryan Crotin, finished sixth place with a 19-21 record.