The second part of the event took place on October 24, 2015, at Montgomery County Fairgrounds Coliseum in Dayton, Ohio.

On September 29, 2015, ROH announced that Glory By Honor XIV would feature a Champions vs. All Stars theme.

On September 18 at All Star Extravaganza VII The All Night Express returned to defeat The Briscoes in an Open Challenge Tag Match.

On September 18 at All Star Extravaganza VII, The Kingdom (Michael Bennett and Matt Taven) defeated The Young Bucks and former ROH World Tag Team Champions The Addiction in a 3-way tag team match after a masked KRD member attacked Christopher Daniels.

On October 7, ROH announced that The Addiction would cash in their rematch clause to face The Kingdom at Glory By Honor XIV.