When Gilmore Guys ended in 2017, Porter started Good Christian Fun with co-host Caroline Ely on the Headgum network.

[2][3][4] The show is intended for anyone interested in the American subculture created by Christians, and has both religious and non-religious listeners.

For instance, the podcast includes a recurring segment dedicated to finding the worst Christian song of all time.

[3][5][6] Some of the more prominent Christian pop culture subjects featured on the show include DC Talk, VeggieTales, and the Left Behind books.

For instance, Emily St. James commented in Vox that the hosts' nostalgia combined with their criticism creates a "great tension" that results in profound and humorous conversations.

[3] Becca James wrote in Vulture that former Christians might be cynical about the show at first, but the hosts do a great job of easing the listener into the conversation.

[1] Similarly, Andrea Sadowski wrote in The Cascade that the podcast is a "soothing balm to my religious trauma.