After about a year of existence, the Board of Trustees dissolved and Church services in the Eagles' Hall were stopped.

In the early years the treasury often lacked the necessary funds to conduct the church's business, and the community was called upon to give their time and talents.

In March 1959 the general assembly authorized the board of trustees to appoint a committee to study the feasibility of building a new church and community center.

On June 21, 1960, by an overwhelming majority, the general assembly voted to purchase the land located at the corner of River Road and Riverview Avenue.

Upon this approval architect William A. Loumos was retained to begin drawing the plans and specifications as recommended by the Board.

Father Anthony N. Pappas, joined the community in January 1959 and, in addition to his clerical duties, served as religious consultant for the new church.

On May 1, 2004, the Archimandrite Alexander Kile was appointed as the new Proistamenos and served for almost seven years until March 2011 when Father Nicholas Pastrikos joined the community.

On Saturday, December 19, Bishop-elect Ioannis of Phocaea was ordained by Archbishop Elpidophoros of America at the Church of St. George in Piscataway, New Jersey.

In his statements to the newspaper The National Herald, the newly ordained bishop stressed that the experience of the history of the Church and the descent of the Holy Spirit caused him enormous tension to the point that it took half an hour to recover after the ordination.

On his part, Archbishop Elpidophoros, addressing the Bishop-elect of Phocaea, Ioannis, stated that, by a blessed happenstance, they found themselves there in Piscataway, “in the parish that you served when you were first ordained a priest.” Addressing those present, the Archbishop of America stressed that many may be surprised to learn that Phocaea, on the coast of Asia Minor, was the center of Hellenic life and thought over two-thousand-five-hundred years ago.

Deacon Simeon was ordained on October 21, 2023, with the presence of His Eminence Bishop Apostolos and Chancellor V. Rev.

[5] Saint George offers convenient parking during Scarlet Knight home games.

The Junior Basketball team is for players ages 12 to 14, or 7th-9th grade, with head coach Yianni Apostolakis.

On December 10, 2022, the senior team won the championship with a lineup of Georgie Papadakis, Evangelos E. Kambitsis, Chris Vlahos, Dimitri Hirschman and Marko Hantsoulis.

In the 2022–2023 season, not much changed, as the two way players stayed the same, with Hantsoulis being eligible to be on the senior team full time.

Despite their success, the core Juniors being Chris Vlahos, Dimitri Hirschman, Evangelos Kambitsis, Andreas Hadjiloucas and Bizos lost to St. Barbara's in Tom's River.

Going into their 2022-2023 Senior season, a much expanded roster with new prospects gives the team a chance to win it all before the class of 2023 graduates.

Greek Orthodox Youth Association of America (GOYA) is an organized group of over fifty children aged 12 to 18, or 7th-12th grade.

[7] The GOYA also has a yearly Olympic competition, where churches from all around New Jersey stay at Monmouth University during Memorial Day weekend to compete in Track and Field, Volleyball, Soccer and Swimming.

Faithful from across the Metropolis of NJ joined Archbishop Elpidophoros of America, Bishop Apostolos of Medeia, Chancellor Archimandrite Christoforos Oikonomidis, and clergy from the Metropolis for Divine Liturgy in the Great Auditorium of Ocean Grove before heading down to the beach.