JCPenney, the last anchor store, was relocated from downtown Greeley in 1987 and built on the south west portion of the mall.

[5] The original main entrance to the Greeley Mall had been on the north side where this Sears and outcropping was built.

[14] Some of the early notable stores in the Greeley Mall were Barbary Cheese, Balanced Diet, Carousel, Zezo's Magic Castle, Foxxmore, Stuarts, Frankies, Qualitat Unlimited, Martin's Shoes, Kenney's Shoes and Natural Music, and organ store.

The mall did not have a food court at the time it was built, but there was a cantina named Godinez that had an outside entrance that faced the north, Dairy Queen, and an Arby's that had a back door exit that was on the south side.

There was a Karmelkorn store in the center of the mall that was the longest standing tenant and an Orange Julius with a Devil themed decor.

Today there are two anchor stores - Cinemark which was built in 2003-04 as part of the 2004 expansion[15] and replaced the Montgomery Ward building.

Originally the mall had a large fountain in the center made up of a series of tall pipes that would splash down on to a yellow tiled base with a mote around it with black iron gates around it.

There was another fountain on the west side that was by the Montgomery Wards entrance that resembled a yucca plant with water spraying in patters to give the appearing of a geodesic dome.

As of 2019, the rest of the building contains (from west to east) Starlight Station, Iglesia De Dios, and Wholesale Hydroponics.

The plan included demolishing the Sears and JCPenney and relocating them to the periphery, adding housing south of the mall, and changing the layout of the entire parking lot.