Opened in 1976, the mall features Dillard's and J. C. Penney as its anchor stores.

Other major tenants of the mall include Jo-Ann Fabrics, Planet Fitness, and Altitude Trampoline Park.

[5] Montgomery Ward went out of business in 2001 and became Sears, which relocated from Midtown Shopping Center.

[6] After Mervyn's closed all of its Colorado locations in 2005, a portion of its store became Sports Authority.

[6] In 2017, an article in The Washington Post acknowledged Pueblo Mall as an example of a smaller shopping mall that has maintained success even in the wake of online shopping, noting the variety of stores, the significant size of the market area, and the high median income surrounding the city of Pueblo.