The club was formed in 1913, entering the FA Cup for the first time in 1929.

[2] After finishing fourth in 1961–62 they were promoted to Division One, but were relegated at the end of the following season.

The following season they won the Premier Division title, however they were denied promotion to the Northern Premier League due to ground grading issues, which resulted in the manager and most of the team leaving.

[2] In 2003 they pulled out of the NCEL and rejoined the Doncaster & District Senior League (D&DSL).

Hatfield spent five years in the CMFL, in which time they won promotion to the Supreme Division, but in 2010 they again rejoined the Doncaster Senior League.