The song was described by music critics as "pop noir",[2] a "Shirley Bassey-strut",[3] a "brass-festooned swagger",[4] "moody and sultry jazz-tinged number"[5] and a "brassy, withering put-down of some unfortunate, sniveling weasel, whose duplicity is exposed in no short order".

MusicOMH named "Here Comes That Day" as one of several tracks on Mantaray which should be an "instant hit".

[7] The Guardian rated it as one of the singles of the week, describing it as "60s pop, replete with severe and sexy vocals", it "aches with a lifetime of insight and colour, yet still manages to sound refreshing and original".

[9] Walesonline rated it as one of the 3 best singles of 2007 saying, it was the "standout highlight" from Mantaray with "dramatic blasts of brass and killer beats.

[11] Due to its popularity, the track entered the UK Singles Chart prior to the official release date, peaking at number 93, but failed to remain in the top 100 following the full release of the single, and fell to number 103.