[1][2] On the verge of his thirtieth birthday, Robert (Rossif Sutherland), a wealthy Wall Street broker, grieves his latest relationship gone awry and questions a loss of meaning and purpose to his career.

Disenchanted with his life, he liquidates his assets and celebrates his newfound freedom that night in a Manhattan bar where he spots the mysterious, attractive Daphne (Karine Vanasse).

Liam Lacey of The Globe and Mail, gave the film two stars out of four, stating, "the plot collapses into a fairy-tale ending that is offered as an odd remedy for the characters’ facile defeatism.

"[4] Peter Howell of the Toronto Star also criticized the plot, stating, "A miscast and mismatched Rossif Sutherland and Karine Vanasse stretch credulity at every quirk-filled turn as they follow a bag of loot and chase family problems on the long trek from New York to Ontario's 'Gateway to the North.'

Barnard gave the film one and a half stars out of four, writing, "Even the sex is dull in I’m Yours, ... Farlinger's Canuck road movie that takes an ill-matched pair from New York to North Bay but ends up going nowhere.

"[3] Joe Leydon of Variety described the film as "entirely predictable and instantly forgettable," noting the leads Rossif Sutherland and Karine Vanesse "do little to distract from the shopworn contrivances of Farlinger’s scenario" while "struggling with sketchy roles and gaping plotholes.

[8] Nathalie Atkinson of the National Post described the film's "ecstasy-fuelled motel room romp" as "coy, urgent, sexy and probably one of the hottest love scenes in a mainstream movie, Canadian or otherwise, in a long time.

"[9] Robert Bell of Exclaim writes, "An overriding theme of chance changing the world fuels the romantic trajectory of the film," which is "touching and ultimately satisfying as a philosophically light love story."