ICC's chief executive officer since 2013, Jacob Baime, is a former national field director for AIPAC.

[6] According to promotional material distributed to potential donors ICC monitors progressive Jewish student groups.

[7] In 2016, ICC campaigned against Palestinian-American poet Remi Kanazi by secretly funding Facebook pages that appeared under the names of fake student organizations.

[10][16] The organization previously received criticism from progressive Jewish student organization Open Hillel, after the ICC recognized the Canary Mission blacklist "for deterring BDS activism and causing students to drop their support for pro-Palestine groups out of fear of repercussions.

"[17] In October 2023, the organization led petitions to multiple universities to withdraw recognition of and funding for Students for Justice in Palestine.