His career started with an American television commercial for Ritz Crackers.
In 2007, he appeared in Chris Fuller's Gotham Award nominated independent feature Loren Cass.
In addition to his acting talents, Reynolds is a trumpet player and a certified aviator.
He also had small roles in Life with Mikey (1993), Safe Men (1998), and For Love of the Game (1999).
Reynolds is the writer of the webtoon series Perish with illustrator Esfi Morales.