[2] As a junior, she averaged 26.1 points, 6.3 rebounds, 6 assists and 5.2 steals per game, sharing Ohio Prep Sportswriters Association Division I Co-Player of the Year with Kierstan Bell.

[4] She averaged 28.3 points, 7.1 rebounds, 6.5 assists and 5.1 steals per game as a senior, earning state Division I Player of the Year honors from the Ohio High School Basketball Coaches Association.

[6] She was a three-time Columbus Dispatch All-Metro Player of the Year and Ohio Miss Basketball finalist in high school.

[10] She was drawn to the school because she was a lifelong Ohio State fan and wanted to remain close to her younger sister, who has Down syndrome.

[15] On November 13, Sheldon scored 14 points and tied the program single-game record with 11 steals in an 82–64 win over Boston College.

Despite being considered a potential first-round pick in the 2023 WNBA draft, Sheldon returned to Ohio State for a fifth season.

[28] On November 12, 2024, Sheldon was announced as the Director of Player Development for Ohio State Buckeyes women's basketball.

Stats current through end of 2024 season Sheldon's father, Duane, played college basketball for Baldwin Wallace before embarking on a coaching career and later becoming the athletic director at Dublin Coffman High School.

[32] In August 2024, Sheldon signed a signature shoe deal with HOLO Footwear, which also gave her an equity stake in the company.