In 1923, Stephens saw more playing time, backing up John Henry Lloyd at shortstop and Judy Johnson at third base.

He hit .229 but played sufficient defense to help the Daisies to their third consecutive pennant and a victory in the Negro World Series against the 1924 champion Monarchs.

Stephens and Rev Cannady were sent to Homestead in exchange for George Britt and Martin Dihigo.

The 1931 Grays are considered one of the best Negro league teams ever to play, compiling 136 wins and losing only 17.

The Grays also sported sluggers Josh Gibson, Chaney White and Oscar Charleston.

In 1932 Stephens joined the Pittsburgh Crawfords, playing alongside Josh Gibson and Satchel Paige.

He joined Stars second baseman Dick Seay as the best double play combination in the league.