[1] She performed as the Shoemaker's Elf and other characters in the original Broadway cast of Shrek The Musical, which starred sister-in-law Sutton Foster, from November 2008[1][6] through July 14, 2009.

[7] Cody appeared in the role of Annie in the musical version of the children's book Henry and Mudge in 2006 at the Lucille Lortel Theatre and received a Drama League Award nomination.

[13] Cody appeared at the Cape Playhouse (Dennis, Massachusetts) in productions of Lend Me a Tenor (as Maggie) in 2007,[14] Moon Over Buffalo in 2009 (as Rosalind) with Gary Beach, John Scherer and her husband, Hunter Foster.

[20] In addition to her role in The Odd Couple, Cody's hometown regional theater, Geva Theatre Center, has seen her play Patsy in Spamalot, Mary in the world premiere of Women in Jeopardy!, and the title character (a labradoodle) in Sylvia.

[23][24] Cody and Don Richard frequently appear at events such as Rosie Live and the Annual BC/EFA Easter Bonnet Competition as their characters from Urinetown, the Musical.

[29] Cody was a series regular on the short-lived CBS television show Untitled Paul Reiser Project (2006), playing Clarissa Ruiz.

[32][33] She can be heard on the cast albums of Andrew Lippa's The Wild Party (2000),[34] Vincent Youmans's Through The Years (2001),[35] The Pajama Game, with Harry Connick Jr. and Kelli O'Hara, Shrek The Musical with Sutton Foster and Brian d'Arcy James (2009),[36] Taboo and Seussical.