Built in the Gothic Revival style between 1910 and 1912 of site manufactured concrete blocks cast to look like stones, it was designed to serve the needs of local Protestants.

Its pulpit and pews, which are still in use, were donated by Henry Morrison Flagler, the developer of the Florida East Coast Railway, whose mainline still runs through Jensen Beach less than a block west of the church.

Harry H. Jones of the Union Congregational Church in nearby Eden also came down to preach on some Sundays and Wednesdays.

In 1962 the congregation by then known as the Jensen Beach Community Church moved to a new building on Skyline Drive.

In 2009 the church exterior was painted a bright yellow with gray trim, but was repainted white in May 2009 in order to gain recognition by the local historic preservation board.