After a season at Garden City, Pennucci transferred to Dana College to finish his career.
Pennucci was named an assistant coach at Loveland High School while he was finishing up his degree at the University of Northern Colorado.
[3] In the fall of 2006, Pennucci was named an assistant coach for the Stony Brook Seawolves baseball program.
[5] Coming off the World Series run, Pennucci was promoted to associate head coach of the Seawolves.
[6] On July 10, 2017, Pennucci was named the head coach at East Tennessee State University.