Butler played for four different NFL franchises during his four year career, finishing up in 1946 with the Bethlehem Bulldogs of the fledgling American Football League.

As a sophomore in 1939, Butler ran 56 yards for a touchdown against the University of Alabama.

In 1943 Butler was drafted into the military due to World War II, however he was physically disqualified for duty.

He then made his first start with the "Steagles" one day after being ruled 4-F by his draft board for poor eyesight and bad knees.

During the 1944 season, Butler was fined $200 by co-coaches Walt Kiesling and Phil Handler for what they characterized as "indifferent play".