Awarding the album four stars at CCM Magazine, Andy Argyrakis states, "Any of the above would’ve fit right beside his memorable material from the ‘90s, though they avoid sounding dated thanks to McBrayer’s well-preserved voice that transcends specific eras.

"[1] Michael Dalton, affixing a three and a half out of five rating upon the album for The Phantom Tollbooth, describes, "This is a strong comeback, one that will appeal to Avalon fans and anyone that appreciates faith-inspired music.

"[5] Giving the album three and a half stars from New Release Today, Marcus Hathcock writes, "Keep Breathing is a milestone for McBrayer that could only improve with some more variety in the production and arrangements.

"[4] Sarah Baylor, allotting the album a four star review by The Christian Beat, says, "Keep Breathing displays Jody McBrayer’s unique vocal range and abilities.

"[2] Kelly Meade, allocating the album a 3.8 star rating from Today's Christian Entertainment, writes, "Throughout Keep Breathing, Jody McBrayer gives a near flawless vocal performance on songs with lyrics that speak to the hearts of listeners capturing your attention from start to finish.