[6] He graduated from the University of British Columbia, in international relations, with a minor in Japanese Language and Culture in May 2019.

[9] When asked in an interview at World Team Trophy, he stated that his favourite Pokémon is Farfetch'd.

At the 2023 Canadian National Championships Reynolds revealed that he was working on his Master's degree in Public Administration.

At the JGP Final, despite suffering from food poisoning,[citation needed] he won the bronze medal after landing his first 4T in competition.

He is the second skater of three in the world, under the ISU Judging System, to land the combination in international competition, after Evgeni Plushenko and before Kevin van der Perren.

At Four Continents, Reynolds led after the short program, and although he faltered in the free skate, the combined score was enough to earn him the bronze medal.

[14] At his first World Championships, Reynolds popped a jump in the short program, but earned the second highest technical score in the free skate portion of the event, finishing in 11th place overall.

[15] At the 2010 Skate Canada International, Reynolds became the first skater to ever land two quadruple jumps in a short program.

In the short program he aggravated a hip injury from December and took time off following the competition, but began training again when he was added to the Canadian team for the 2011 World Championships, replacing Shawn Sawyer who had dropped out.

He took the silver medal at the 2012 Canadian Championships and was selected to represent Canada at the 2012 Four Continents and 2012 Worlds.

During the 2012–13 season, Reynolds finished fifth and sixth, respectively, at his two Grand Prix events, the 2012 Cup of China and the 2012 NHK Trophy.

In the 2013–14 season, Reynolds withdrew from his two Grand Prix events due to skate boot problems.

[20][21] He took the silver medal at the 2014 Canadian Championships and was selected to represent Canada at the 2014 Winter Olympics in Sochi.

In the 2014–15 season, Reynolds again withdrew from his two Grand Prix assignments due to injury and skate boot issues.